Stand Your Ground

Under § 13A-3-23, you are legally justified in using deadly force if you reasonably believe another person is:

• Using or about to use unlawful deadly physical force against you or a third person
• Committing or about to commit a kidnapping (§ 13A-6-43 or § 13A-6-44)
• Committing or about to commit a forcible rape or sodomy (§ 13A-6-61 or § 13A-6-63)
• Committing or about to commit a robbery in the first or second degree (§ 13A-8-41 or § 13A-8-42)
• Committing or about to commit a first or second-degree assault (§ 13A-6-20 or § 13A-6-21)
• Committing or about to commit a first or second-degree burglary (§ 13A-7-5 or § 13A-7-6)
• Unlawfully and forcibly entering or has entered your dwelling, residence, or occupied vehicle

You do not need to prove the other person was actually committing any of these offenses , only that you reasonably believed they were. The standard is what a reasonable person in your position would have believed under the same circumstances, based on the information available at the time.

Alabama's immunity process is one of the strongest self-defense protections in the country. Under § 13A-3-23(d), a defendant who claims self-defense immunity is entitled to a pre-trial hearing before a judge , not a jury. At this hearing, the defendant must show by a preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not) that their use of force was legally justified.

If the judge grants immunity, the case is dismissed entirely. The defendant is immune from criminal prosecution and from any civil lawsuit arising from the use of force. This is not an acquittal after trial , it is dismissal before trial, with full immunity attached. The state cannot retry the case, and the alleged victim cannot sue.

If immunity is denied, the case proceeds to trial, where self-defense remains available as an affirmative defense before the jury. A denial of immunity at the pre-trial hearing does not prevent a jury from finding self-defense at trial , it simply means the judge found the evidence insufficient at the preponderance standard, while the jury evaluates the evidence under the reasonable doubt standard.

Alabama's Stand Your Ground law is not limited to your home. The statute protects the use of force in any location where you have a legal right to be:

• Your dwelling or residence - the Castle Doctrine under § 13A-3-25 creates a presumption of reasonable belief when someone forcibly enters your home
• Your occupied vehicle - the same presumption applies to forcible entry into your vehicle
• Your workplace - including business premises, whether you are the owner, employee, or authorized occupant
• Any public or private place - including parking lots, sidewalks, stores, restaurants, and any other location where you are lawfully present

The law eliminates any duty to retreat regardless of location. You do not have to try to run, hide, or escape before defending yourself. However, the force used must still be reasonable under the circumstances.

The law provides significant protections, but it does not cover every situation. You cannot claim Stand Your Ground immunity if:

• You were the initial aggressor — if you started the physical confrontation, you cannot claim self-defense unless you completely withdrew and communicated that withdrawal before the other person continued the attack
• You were engaged in unlawful activity — commission of a crime at the time of the incident disqualifies you from immunity
• You used force against a law enforcement officer — performing official duties in a manner the defendant knew or should have known was lawful
• The situation involved mutual combat — a consensual fight is not self-defense
• The force used was disproportionate — the force must be reasonable and proportional to the threat perceived

These limitations are the elements prosecutors use to defeat a Stand Your Ground claim. Our attorneys evaluate every factual detail to determine whether any limitation applies and to build the strongest immunity argument possible.

At JB Brown Criminal Trial Practice, we evaluate self-defense claims from the moment you retain us and prepare every case for the immunity hearing.

Building the Immunity Case

We investigate the full sequence of events — who initiated contact, what each party said and did, the physical positioning, the threat perceived, and whether the defendant had any alternative. We obtain and analyze surveillance footage, body camera recordings, 911 call recordings, witness statements, and forensic evidence to reconstruct the incident and establish that the use of force was reasonable.

Challenging the State's Narrative

Prosecutors defeat Stand Your Ground claims by arguing the defendant was the initial aggressor, used disproportionate force, or was engaged in unlawful activity. We attack each of these arguments with evidence. We present witnesses, expert testimony on use-of-force standards, and forensic evidence that supports the defendant's account.

The Immunity Hearing

The pre-trial immunity hearing is a critical moment. A successful hearing ends the case entirely — no trial, no conviction, no criminal record. We prepare for the immunity hearing with the same intensity we bring to a full jury trial, because the outcome at this stage determines everything.

Our attorneys have secured dismissals in murder, assault, and violent crime cases through Stand Your Ground immunity hearings across Alabama. For cases involving a death, see our homicide defense page. For information on how Aniah's Law affects bail in cases involving deadly force, see our explainer.